Blog
Outlier of the Week: “Kids these days. No respect..!” (28.7×)
A 10-slide story carousel by @victorianpoetry got 586,694 likes and comments, 28.7× the creator’s usual of about 20,440. The numbers, the hook and how to reuse it.
This week’s biggest outlier is a story carousel by @victorianpoetry that got 586,694 likes and comments, 28.7× the creator’s usual. Its first slide puts a snap judgement next to the reply that undoes it: “Kids these days. No respect..! ‘Since chemo, I can’t stand for five minutes.’”
It was posted on 15 November (UTC), has 10 slides and sits in the psychology niche. The next-highest score among this week’s twelve top outliers was 16×.
The numbers
- Score: 28.7× the creator’s usual.
- Likes + comments: 586,694.
- The creator’s usual: about 20,440 likes and comments (586,694 ÷ 28.7).
- Slides: 10.
- Format and niche: story, psychology.
This is a big account, and a usual of about 20,440 is already a lot. That is why the score matters more than the raw count: on its own track record, this carousel did nearly twenty-nine times what a typical post there gets.
It isn’t the account’s first break-out. At the end of September, @victorianpoetry posted “Don’t get too drunk. Don’t drink from an open cup.”, which now scores 56.9× with 2,385,045 likes and comments. A second carousel from this week, “Your birth month your karma:”, scored 6.7×.
What does the first slide say?
“Kids these days. No respect..! ‘Since chemo, I can’t stand for five minutes.’” — @victorianpoetry, 28.7×
The slide has two voices. The first is the familiar complaint about young people; the second is a single quoted line that tells you the complaint was wrong. The reader swipes to find out who said what, and to whom.
In our 10 hook patterns, it is the comeback: quote what someone says, then answer it, a tiny story in one slide. Here the twist is that the answer doesn’t win an argument. It changes how the first line reads. The caption makes the point plainly: “I judge people way faster than I should.”
Why did this carousel work?
We can’t see inside anyone’s audience, so this is a reading of the evidence, not a certainty. Here is what the data shows, and what it doesn’t.
The hook breaks two of the averages. In our sample of 11,966 transcribed first slides, mostly-capitals hooks beat their creator’s usual 44.6% of the time, against 47.8% for normal case. This one is in capitals. At 13 words it sits in the 11–15 band, which reached 2× its creator’s usual 22.7% of the time; the 6–10 band did best at 25.2%. Small gaps, and this post went past both.
It is a statement, not a question. Statements reached 2× 23.0% of the time, against 19.9% for question hooks. The slide asks nothing; it lets the contrast do the work.
The slide count is in a strong band. In our sample of 16,996 scored carousels, those with exactly 10 slides reached 2× their creator’s usual 25.8% of the time, close behind 11–15 slides (26.6%) and 16–20 (25.9%), and above the overall 23.3%. Ten slides also matches the median psychology outlier in the library and sits one above the median story outlier (9).
The format and niche aren’t the explanation. Story carousels reached 2× at 23.2%, almost exactly the overall rate. Psychology carousels did so 21.5% of the time, below average. Neither makes a result like this likely on its own. Browse more story carousel examples to see the range.
One caveat applies to all of these figures: they are base rates across a mix of creators we track, and a correlation is not a cause. Ten-slide carousels reach 2× more often; that doesn’t mean adding slides will.
How to use it in your own niche
You don’t need a hospital story to borrow this structure. You need an assumption your audience makes too quickly. Here is how to remix it, following the same process as Artem’s remix case study.
- Write the snap judgement people make in your niche, then the line that answers it. A client who “never replies”, a colleague who “always leaves early”. Put the judgement first and the reply in quotation marks, and keep the whole slide short.
- Use the next slides to tell the situation behind the reply, one beat per slide. The first slide raises “what happened?”; each slide after it should answer a little more. This one used 10.
- End on what it changed for you, in one line. The caption here owns the mistake in a sentence. Your last slide can do the same, without a list of tips attached.
Keep the structure and replace everything else: your situation, your words, your visuals. Don’t reuse the creator’s slides or story, and don’t borrow someone’s illness for a post. Use a moment that is yours to tell.
For more first slides from this niche, browse psychology carousel ideas.
Frequently asked questions
What was the top Instagram carousel outlier this week?
A story carousel by @victorianpoetry, posted on 15 November (UTC), with 586,694 likes and comments. That is 28.7× the creator’s usual of about 20,440, the highest score among this week’s twelve top outliers in our library.
What is a comeback hook on a carousel?
A first slide that quotes something people say and then answers it, so the slide tells a tiny story on its own. This week’s outlier uses a judgement and a reply that shows the judgement was wrong.
Do all-caps first slides hurt a carousel?
Slightly, on average. In our sample of 11,966 first slides, mostly-capitals hooks beat their creator’s usual 44.6% of the time, against 47.8% for normal case. This week’s top outlier is in capitals, which shows the gap is a nudge, not a rule.